Close
Updated:

The Value Of Economic Expert Witnesses

In Getting The Full Value Of Economic Experts In IP Litigation: A Qualified Expert Is Key, attorney Devon Zastrow Newman of Schwabe, Williamson & Wyatt, P.C., writes:

A plaintiff’s claims in intellectual property litigation may take several forms, including assertion of claims of infringement of the IP right or loss of the plaintiff’s right to the IP through unlawful misappropriation (e.g., trade secret theft). To prevail, the plaintiff must establish three elements: the defendant’s breach of the IP right belonging to the plaintiff; the defendant’s breach damaged the plaintiff; and the measure of damages the plaintiff accrued as a direct cause of the defendant’s breach. An economic expert may be the key to establishing the third element.

When is an economic expert needed?

Expert witness testimony is necessary when a party must present evidence outside a juror’s common knowledge, which applies to nearly all (IP) cases. A technical expert explains the technology and whether it is infringed by the defendant. The plaintiff may use an economic expert to explain how economic damages occurred. The defendant’s economic expert, if any, will present an alternative view of the damages.

Most IP cases are litigated in federal court; thus, the expert’s testimony must be admissible under Federal Rules of Evidence 702 and 703. These rules require that the expert be qualified to testify about the subject matter and perform the analysis using qualified information he or she has personally reviewed. The expert must base his or her opinion on facts or data that are the type of information experts in the field would rely on to form an opinion. A party may challenge an expert’s testimony through a pre-trial motion if it fails to abide by FRE Rules 702 or 703. Challenges typically come in pre-trial motions to limit or preclude the testimony. Finally, the expert’s opinions must be relevant to the issues and help the jurors understand them.

Read more here.

Devon Zastrow Newman leads the Intellectual Property Litigation Group at Schwabe, Williamson & Wyatt, P.C. She focuses her practice on intellectual property and complex litigation, and has extensive experience representing patent and trademark owners in infringement actions.

Contact Us